ICON EV i40L vs. Star EV J Model 4+2
By The Smith Family, reviewed by Brad · Independent, no paid placement · Last verified Jul 30, 2026
ICON EV i40L takes it. It wins on the better price and warranty. These sit in different divisions (premium vs. value), so weigh the price gap accordingly. The full side-by-side of verified specs is below — every figure carries a source and a verification date.
Key takeaways
- The ICON EV i40L beats the Star EV J Model 4+2 on the better price and warranty. They sit in different divisions (premium vs value), so weigh the price gap.
- Range: the Star EV J Model 4+2 goes up to 31 mi per charge vs the ICON EV i40L's 30 mi.
- Vehicle warranty: the ICON EV i40L carries 3 years vs the Star EV J Model 4+2's 2.
- Florida out-the-door (6% state sales tax + ~1% county surtax on the first $5,000, FLHSMV title + initial registration): the ICON EV i40L lands about $10,422 and the Star EV J Model 4+2 about $15,717, base build before kits and dealer-quoted delivery.
- Both the ICON EV i40L and the Star EV J Model 4+2 are factory-certified LSVs, confirmed against the NHTSA vPIC registry.
Head to head · Tampa Bay Edition
ICON EV i40L vs. Star EV J Model 4+2
LAST VERIFIED 07/30/2026
| ICON EVi40LWinner | Star EVJ Model 4+2 | |
|---|---|---|
| MSRP range | $9,500 – $11,495 | $14,495 |
| Top speed | 25 mph†1 | 25 mph†2 |
| Range (low) | 25 mi†1 | 31 mi✓†2 |
| Range (high) | 30 mi†1 | 31 mi✓†2 |
| Battery type | lithium†3 | lithium†2 |
| Battery capacity | 105 Ah†3 | 105 Ah†2 |
| System voltage | 51 V†3 | 48 V†2 |
| Seats | 4†4 | 6✓†2 |
| Length | 113 in†4 | 134 in†2 |
| Width | 53 in†4 | 47 in†2 |
| Height | 82 in†4 | 75 in†2 |
| Curb weight | 1,300 lb†4 | 1,345 lb†2 |
| Motor power | 5 kW†4 | 5 kW†2 |
| Brakes | Four-wheel disc, electromagnetic parking brake†4 | Front disc, rear drum†2 |
| Suspension | MacPherson-style independent front, solid-axle coil-over rear†4 | McPherson coil spring†2 |
| Display size | 10.1 in✓†3 | 7 in†2 |
| Warranty | 3 yr✓†5 | 2 yr†2 |
| Battery warranty | — | 6.5 yr†2 |
| LSV certified (street-legal capable) | Yes†6 | Yes†7 |
| Ground clearance | — | 4 in†2 |
| Turning radius | — | 15 ft†2 |
| Range, normalized◆ computed | ~43 mi✓ | ~40 mi |
◆ Range, normalized is our figure, not the maker's: each pack's energy at a standard 0.125 kWh/mile, the same on every cart — an apples-to-apples check on the “up to” range claims above, which are usually measured at 19 mph on the largest optional pack.
◆ The verdict
It wins on the better price and warranty. These sit in different divisions (premium vs. value), so weigh the price gap accordingly.
Save $4,995 vs the Star EV J Model 4+2
Why it won
◆ Price the fight — Florida out-the-door
Florida out-the-door estimates (6% state sales tax + ~1% county surtax on the first $5,000, FLHSMV title + initial registration): the ICON EV i40L lands at about $10,422 and the Star EV J Model 4+2 at about $15,717, base build, before kits and dealer-quoted delivery.
ICON EV i40Lbase build · FL out-the-door
est. $167.07/mo — 20% down, 7.5% APR, 60 mo. Confirm real rates with the lender.
Star EV J Model 4+2base build · FL out-the-door
est. $251.95/mo — 20% down, 7.5% APR, 60 mo. Confirm real rates with the lender.
METHODOLOGY — what's verified, what's estimated
Green ✓ marks the better verified figure where the two differ. Verdict scored on the verified specs above — factory-LSV status gates the win.
Rather skip the configurator? Get a dealer quote on either cart:
Frequently asked
- Is the ICON EV i40L or the Star EV J Model 4+2 better?
- ICON EV i40L takes it. It wins on the better price and warranty. These sit in different divisions (premium vs. value), so weigh the price gap accordingly.
- What do the i40L and J Model 4+2 cost out the door in Florida?
- Florida out-the-door estimates (6% state sales tax + ~1% county surtax on the first $5,000, FLHSMV title + initial registration): the ICON EV i40L lands at about $10,422 and the Star EV J Model 4+2 at about $15,717, base build, before kits and dealer-quoted delivery. MSRPs are verified and sourced; taxes and fees are labeled estimates with the method disclosed. Configure both carts with kits at golfcartshowdown.com/build/compare.